📖 微观供需综合练习

Economics

I. Lesson Focus

This lesson integrates all core microeconomic concepts from the demand and supply topic set: equilibrium determination, shifts versus movements along curves, price and income elasticities, government interventions (price ceilings, floors, taxes, subsidies), consumer and producer surplus, and deadweight loss. The focus is on applying these tools simultaneously to complex scenarios, which is the most common format in the CFA Level I Economics section.

II. The Problem

A city simultaneously imposes a price ceiling on taxi fares and a minimum wage for drivers while fuel prices rise sharply. Candidates must determine how the new equilibrium price and quantity change, how consumer and producer surplus are redistributed, whether shortages or surpluses emerge, and how different elasticity values alter policy outcomes. These integrated scenarios represent the highest-frequency question type on the CFA Level I exam.

III. Demand-Supply Equilibrium Review and Graphical Analysis

Market equilibrium occurs at the intersection of the downward-sloping demand curve and the upward-sloping supply curve, where quantity demanded equals quantity supplied (Qd = Qs). Any exogenous shock—changes in income, input costs, tastes, expectations, or government policy—shifts one or both curves and produces a new equilibrium.

• Increase in demand (rightward shift): P↑, Q↑
• Increase in supply (rightward shift): P↓, Q↑
• Decrease in demand (leftward shift): P↓, Q↓
• Decrease in supply (leftward shift): P↑, Q↓

Consumer surplus (CS) is the area below the demand curve and above the equilibrium price line. Producer surplus (PS) is the area above the supply curve and below the equilibrium price line. Total surplus (TS = CS + PS) is maximized at the competitive equilibrium when there are no externalities or distortions.

IV. Comprehensive Effects of Price Interventions

1. Price Ceiling: Set below equilibrium, it creates a shortage (Qd > Qs). Shortage size = Qd(Pc) – Qs(Pc).
   Consumer surplus is partly transferred to producers and partly lost as deadweight loss (DWL). Black markets often emerge.

2. Price Floor: Set above equilibrium, it creates a surplus (Qs > Qd). Common examples include minimum wages and agricultural support prices.
   Producer surplus may rise for those who remain employed, but unemployment or inventories appear and DWL is created.

3. Per-unit Tax: Shifts the supply curve leftward. Tax incidence depends on the relative elasticities of supply and demand.
   The side with lower elasticity bears more of the tax burden.
   Buyer’s price = Seller’s net price + tax.

4. Subsidy: Shifts supply rightward, lowers the price paid by buyers, creates excess supply, and generates DWL funded by taxpayers.

V. The Central Role of Elasticity in Demand-Supply Analysis

Elasticity measures responsiveness and determines policy effectiveness and burden sharing.

• Price Elasticity of Demand: $E_d = \left| \frac{\% \Delta Q_d}{\% \Delta P} \right|$.
  |Ed| > 1 = elastic, |Ed| < 1 = inelastic, = 1 = unit elastic.

• Price Elasticity of Supply: $E_s = \frac{\% \Delta Q_s}{\% \Delta P}$.

• Cross-price Elasticity: Positive for substitutes, negative for complements.

• Income Elasticity: Positive for normal goods, negative for inferior goods.

Elasticity dictates tax incidence and DWL magnitude: the more inelastic the demand, the greater the consumer share of a tax; the more elastic the supply, the easier it is for producers to exit.

VI. Calculating Consumer and Producer Surplus

For linear demand, CS is the triangular area: $CS = \frac{1}{2} \times (P_{max} - P) \times Q$.
Producer surplus is calculated symmetrically. After any intervention, candidates must identify the transfer of surplus between consumers and producers plus the triangular DWL.

Worked Cases

Case 1: Fuel Price Increase in the Taxi Market

Demand: $Q_d = 1200 - 80P$
Supply: $Q_s = 200 + 40P$ (P in yuan/km, Q in thousand vehicle-km/day)

Initial equilibrium:
$1200 - 80P = 200 + 40P \Rightarrow 1000 = 120P \Rightarrow P^ = 10$, $Q^ = 400$.

Fuel cost increase shifts supply to $Q_s = 100 + 40P$.
New equilibrium: $1200 - 80P = 100 + 40P \Rightarrow P^{} = 9.17$, $Q^{} = 266.7$.

Price rises 16.7 %, quantity falls 33.3 %. Both CS and PS decline; total surplus falls due to DWL.

Case 2: Simultaneous Price Ceiling and Minimum Wage

Using the original equilibrium (P = 10, Q = 400), the government sets a fare ceiling of 9 yuan and a minimum wage that further shifts supply left to $Q_s = 50 + 40P$.

At Pc = 9:
Qd = 1200 – 80 × 9 = 480
Qs = 50 + 40 × 9 = 410
Shortage = 70 thousand vehicle-km.

Consumer surplus appears to increase from the lower price, but waiting costs and unserved demand reduce effective welfare. Producer surplus effects are mixed: some drivers benefit from higher wages, others become unemployed.

Case 3: Tax Incidence under Different Demand Elasticities

Demand A (elastic): $Q_d = 800 - 40P$, Ed ≈ 1.33 at P = 10
Demand B (inelastic): $Q_d = 500 - 10P$, Ed ≈ 0.25 at P = 10
Supply: $Q_s = 200 + 20P$

Initial equilibrium ≈ P = 13.33, Q ≈ 466.7. A per-unit tax of 2 is imposed.

Scenario A (elastic demand): Buyers pay ≈ 14.44, sellers receive ≈ 12.44; consumers bear ≈ 55 % of tax, quantity falls to ≈ 422.
Scenario B (inelastic demand): Buyers pay ≈ 14.8, sellers receive ≈ 12.8; consumers bear ≈ 73 % of tax, quantity falls only to ≈ 452.

Conclusion: The more inelastic the demand, the larger the share of tax borne by consumers and the smaller the reduction in quantity.

Traps

Key Formulas

• Equilibrium condition: $Q_d(P) = Q_s(P)$
• Price elasticity of demand: $E_d = \left| \frac{\Delta Q}{\Delta P} \times \frac{P}{Q} \right|$
• Linear demand elasticity: $E_d = \frac{bP}{a - bP}$ (for $Q_d = a - bP$)
• Consumer share of tax: $\frac{E_s}{E_s + E_d}$
• Consumer surplus (linear): $CS = \frac{1}{2} \times Base \times Height$
• Deadweight loss (linear tax): $DWL = \frac{1}{2} \times \Delta Q \times tax$
• Shortage under price ceiling: $Q_d(P_c) - Q_s(P_c)$
• Total surplus maximized under competitive equilibrium without externalities or interventions

Practice Questions

Q1. A good has price elasticity of demand of 0.6 and supply elasticity of 1.5. A per-unit tax of 10 is imposed. The percentage of the tax borne by consumers is closest to:
A. 28%　B. 71%　C. 40%　D. 60%

Q2. A government sets an agricultural price floor above the equilibrium price. The most likely result is:
A. Shortage and deadweight loss
B. Surplus and deadweight loss
C. Increase in total surplus
D. Producer surplus must decline

Q3. Which change causes the demand curve to shift right?
A. Consumer income falls and the good is normal
B. Price of a substitute falls
C. Price of a complement falls
D. Own price of the good falls

Q4. For the linear demand $Q_d = 600 - 30P$, the price elasticity at P = 10 is:
A. 0.5　B. 1.0　C. 2.0　D. 0.67

Q5. Simultaneous imposition of a price ceiling and a per-unit subsidy to producers will most likely:
A. Always create a shortage
B. Increase equilibrium quantity but still generate DWL
C. Definitely increase total surplus
D. Reduce consumer surplus

Q6. A cross-price elasticity of +1.8 indicates the two goods are most likely:
A. Complements　B. Substitutes　C. Inferior goods　D. Giffen goods

Q7. Initial equilibrium: P = 20, Q = 500. After a per-unit tax of 5, new buyer price = 23, seller net price = 19, quantity = 450. Deadweight loss is closest to:
A. 12.5　B. 25　C. 50　D. 100

Q8. In a competitive market, a tax is placed on a necessity with highly inelastic demand. The most likely long-run outcome is:
A. Producers bear most of the tax
B. Consumers bear most of the tax and quantity falls sharply
C. Consumers bear most of the tax but quantity falls very little
D. Black-market activity shrinks

Answers

Takeaways

• Only exogenous non-price factors shift demand or supply curves; price changes cause movements along the curves.
• Tax incidence is determined by the ratio of supply to demand elasticities; inelastic demand leads to higher consumer burden.
• Any binding price ceiling below or floor above equilibrium creates deadweight loss and reduces total surplus.
• Consumer surplus lies below the demand curve and above price; producer surplus lies above the supply curve and below price.
• Elasticity is the key tool for predicting policy outcomes, incidence, and surplus changes; linear demand elasticity must be calculated routinely.
• Integrated exam questions frequently combine policy, elasticity, surplus redistribution, and equilibrium shifts—sketching the graph is essential for clear analysis.